£8,800 and 7 years later my chimney leak is finally fixed – but it turns out I didn't need to spend that much time or money
Got a water ingress issue that’s getting you down? Our home renovator explains how what looks like a major problem can sometimes be fixed with simpler solutions than you might expect
Every morning for 7 years, I woke up looking at my biggest problem. Upon opening my eyes each day, I was greeted by a large damp patch on the chimney breast opposite my bed, a daunting reminder that my chimney was still leaking no matter how many times I’d attempted to fix it. I was living every homeowner’s worst nightmare.
The chimney in question is on the gable end of my semi-detached house and runs from the master bedroom down to the living room. I have a log burner installed in the living room fireplace so one chimney flue is active, whilst the other remains out of use as the fireplace in the master bedroom was blocked up prior to my ownership.
So, if you’re currently at the mercy of a problematic chimney, hold tight and continue reading. As well as sharing the tell-tale signs, I'll reveal the right advice I finally had that led me to simpler solutions than I’d expected.
How I spotted the issue and tried to fix it
Unbelievably, the leak revealed itself the very first time I visited the house after picking up the keys. I remember the disappointment of discovering a hidden problem so soon, as I noticed small trails of water running down the Artex (which was soon plastered over) on the chimney breast in the bedroom. Failed lead flashing is one of the most common causes of chimney leaks so I took a punt on the most obvious solution and paid for the flashing to be replaced.
It turned out that the flashing wasn’t the problem, because a few months after I moved in, a damp patch began to appear in the bedroom, which had been replastered during the initial house renovations. The damp emerged where the chimney breast meets the ceiling, at the side of the active flue. By this time, I’d realised my roof wasn’t in great condition and because the damp appeared to be on the ceiling, I contacted a different roofer who replaced several broken slates.
Little did I know that my first winter living in the house would expose the true extent of the water ingress and how futile my initial repairs had been.
Whenever it rained heavily, water would leak out of the unused rear flue outlet on my log burner and run across the hearth. The log burner installer suggested the rain must be getting in through the cowl and returned with a more weather-proof replacement. Meanwhile, the damp on the bedroom chimney breast became a bigger problem as the patch crept from ceiling level to halfway down the wall.
Bring your dream home to life with expert advice, how to guides and design inspiration. Sign up for our newsletter and get two free tickets to a Homebuilding & Renovating Show near you.
That winter a few small damp patches also appeared around the edges of my bedroom ceiling, in places where the roof met with the exterior walls. As a fairly inexperienced renovator at that time, I convinced myself that my roof, which every passing tradesperson seemed to have an opinion on, was the root of all evil. I found a reputable roofer and spent a lot of money on full roof replacement costs.
What I found especially challenging about resolving my chimney woes, as with all damp-related issues, was the element of seasonality. The problem only showed up during the winter or particularly wet spells, making it difficult to assess the severity and keep track of whether the things I was doing to fix the leak were working or not.
Top tip: Don’t make assumptions based on a few hours of Googling and certainly don’t pay heed to the opinions of tradespeople who aren’t experts in the issue you’re experiencing.
Unfortunately, the persistent problem was still causing damage
I headed confidently into another winter with my shiny new slate roof, unprepared for further problems with the log burner. During downpours, water would still pool in the bottom of the log burner, seeping out of the body and the rear flue outlet into the fireplace. It was so bad that on several occasions I soaked a litre of water up from the ashpan.
Several email exchanges with the log burner installer revealed that the chimney pot on the active flue is larger than average, so I agreed to try another type of cowl, and I approved the application of sealant between the pot and the cowl to ensure that rain couldn’t drive in between the two. However, I’d lost faith in the installer so I logged a complaint with HETAS, who investigated and put the issues down to condensation.
Unconvinced by this assessment, because the issues with the log burner and bedroom damp always coincided with heavy rain, I decided to have the whole chimney stack renovated by my trusted roofer. I went for the full works: the stack was completely repointed and sealed with Thompson’s Water Seal, the flaunching was replaced, and the redundant flue received a new pepper pot cap to improve ventilation.
Following the chimney stack spruce-up, the damp on and around the bedroom chimney breast seemed to stabilise, but the log burner continued to leak in heavy rain, albeit to a lesser extent. By now I felt that I had exhausted all of my options and accepted this was as good as it was going to get. I resolved to light the fire on a more regular basis in order to keep everything as dry as possible.
Years of fighting with my troublesome chimney left a path of destruction throughout my home. In my bedroom the ceiling was crumbling and the plaster on the chimney breast was in need of replacement. Whilst down in my living room, the body of my beloved log burner had begun to corrode.
But it was the record-breaking rainfall of January 2026 that finally forced me to wake up and properly resolve the issue, as a huge new damp patch on the inactive side of the bedroom chimney breast emerged and spread on to the gable end wall, bringing the salts out of the brickwork with it.
Top tip: Try not to mark an issue as resolved just because you’re emotionally exhausted with it, and remember there are always more avenues to explore.
An expert identified the problem and solutions
To be completely honest, I felt at a total loss. The cause of the water ingress still eluded me, despite the fact I had spent £8,800 and tried so many different repairs over the years. I knew I needed some independent advice and to carry out a proper investigation into the cause of the problem.
I posted a desperate plea for help on my renovation social media channels, which led me to book a consultation with a heritage surveyor – a professional who specialises in traditionally constructed buildings – via an advice service called Expertible. What I liked about Expertible was that it was created by a fellow renovator who understands the importance of getting trustworthy advice from someone who is knowledgeable, and who doesn’t have a vested interest in selling their services.
The consultation took place via video call and I was asked to supply as much information as I could about the chimney-related issues in advance. This 45-minute session cost £145 and revealed several potential problem areas:
- Insufficient ventilation – The surveyor explained that, although he didn’t believe condensation to be the cause of the issues I was experiencing, it is best practice to ventilate unused chimney flues at both the top and bottom to allow for plenty of airflow. Any moisture within a redundant flue can migrate over to the active flue and penetrate through plaster.
- A poor-quality cowl – The surveyor advised that the cowl my chimney was currently sporting was just a cheap option likely bought off Amazon. Apparently, it’s a very common problem with these types of cowls that wind-driven rain comes in through the bird guard and goes down the flue liner. A more specialist cowl that significantly mitigates rain ingress was recommended.
- A fault in the chimney stack – Having examined some photographs of our chimney stack, the surveyor confirmed that the lead flashing adhered to the flashing designs in the Lead Sheet Training Academy for rolled lead guidance. With the flashing ruled out, I was advised that the flaunching or condition of the pointing were the most likely culprits.
Top tip: When an issue persists over a long period of time seek independent advice to gain an unbiased opinion from an expert, which will mitigate against possible conflicts of interest.
How I fixed my leaking chimney
Armed with the knowledge imparted by the independent surveyor, I hired scaffolding so that I could safely access the chimney stack and understand what was really going on. Upon closer inspection, I found several cracks of varying sizes in the flaunching, along with a surprising discovery. Whilst the chimney stack pointing was still in immaculate condition, there was a significant amount of crumbling, cracked and missing mortar between the gable end brickwork, which was allowing rain to track directly into the chimney breast below the roofline. That would explain all of the damp patches in my bedroom.
Having learnt some skills from my grandad, who was a builder, I decided to tackle the repairs myself and drafted in additional support from my dad, who is a chartered engineer and a highly experienced home renovator.
In order to repair the flaunching, we ground each crack out a little wider using an angle grinder fitted with a diamond blade. Then, having made sure the cracks were free of any debris, we filled them with a fire-resistant sealant which is flexible and will absorb any minor movement in future. The sealant cost £9.19 and the angle grinder blade was around £23.
Replacing the cowl was straightforward. I ordered a model recommended by the surveyor, the Brewer Ultimate Flue Outlet Round Multifuel Chimney Cowl from Roof Giant which was suitable for my larger-than-average chimney pot and had a superior weather-proof design.
To do this we cut away all of the sealant between the pot and cowl using a Stanley knife, removed the old cowl from the flue liner, attached the replacement and secured the new cowl to the pot using the stainless-steel fixing strap provided with it. Including delivery, the new cowl set me back £61.76.
Renewing the pointing on the gable end of the house involved removing all of the damaged areas of mortar using an angle grinder, and then repointing between the brickwork using a pointing trowel and a bag of Blue Circle Quality Assured Mortar mix from B&Q.
Astonishingly, as I already owned a set of trowels, this only cost me £12.90 for the mortar mix and £8.24 for a new tub, which I used to combine the mortar mix with water.
Products I used to repair my chimney leak
A black silicone that is suitable for use on non-porous surfaces and withstands heat up to 300°C
This cordless angle grinder has a three-point handle for flexibility and blade guard to provide protection from sparks
This set of trowels includes a range of sizes and was ideal for repointing work
The results
It’s been six months since I carried out the repairs on my leaking chimney. Although I’ve only completed the external works so far, I haven’t had a single drop of moisture inside my log burner, and the damp patches in my bedroom appear to have dried out.
Internally, I still plan to add ventilation to the unused bedroom chimney flue, get the damaged plaster repaired, and rejuvenate my rusty log burner with some wire wool and stove blacking.
My final word of advice for any homeowner who’s battling with a perturbing chimney problem? The apparent scale of the issue isn’t always reflective of the cost or complexity of the solution. I thought I was dealing with a major defect and spent a huge amount of money on works that improved the overall condition of my home but didn’t address the root cause. If I’d looked for the simpler explanation sooner, I might have spared myself years of worry and water ingress.
Thinking of undertaking more work on your chimney (leaking aside)? Find out what to know before removing a chimney breast, and what you can expect to pay for chimney stack removal costs.
Alice Ostapjuk-Wise is a freelance content creator, writer and marketing communications consultant from Leeds. Alice’s love of DIY started young, laying paths in the garden of her family home and learning to point as a teenager with her grandad, who was a builder. Alice is currently renovating her first house, DIYing as many projects as possible and documenting the journey at GiveItaGoReno on Instagram and TikTok.