When it comes to insulating a roof, your choices will depend on:
- your roof type (flat or pitched)
- its structure (depth of the rafters)
- your willingness to invest
In most cases, extra investment made in beating the Building Regulations on insulation is money well spent — it gives a lot back in returns.
Insulating a roof is perhaps the easiest of all the energy-saving home improvements. Mineral wool rolls are ubiquitous and cheap, meaning a whole roof on a standard home could be insulated to the recommended 270mm with a spend of little more than £200.
It’s also within the capability of most DIYers, although not the most pleasant of tasks. And the effect it will have on your energy bills depends on what you’re replacing and how big your roof is. It’s also much more important to do if you don’t have any loft insulation at all.
Building Regulations for Insulating a Roof
Heat rises, and therefore the Building Regulations requirements for heat loss through roofs are more stringent than those for walls.
The limiting U value (the maximise U value which cannot be exceeded) required under current Building Regulations for the roof is 0.20W/m².
How to Insulate a Roof
The first decision is whether to insulate a pitched roof at ceiling or rafter level. The current trend is for a ‘warm roof’ where insulation is installed between the rafters, thereby keeping the roof timbers warm.
With a flat roof, this issue does not arise, but the U value constraint and the amount of insulation needed is just the same.
Achieving a U value of 0.20W/m² (meaning your roof will be better insulated than your walls) will need 120mm thickness of rigid foam or 200mm of mineral wool or natural insulation. Hitting amazing levels of 0.13W/m² will need 300mm of mineral wool or 180mm of rigid foam.
With a warm roof the usual process is to split the insulation into two layers. If 180mm is to be installed then 100mm board might be introduced between the rafters (there has to be a minimum 25mm air gap between the insulation and the underside of the tiles or slates) with an 80mm board running across the rafters.
The proportions do not matter but this arrangement helps to eliminate any draughts caused by gaps between the insulation and the rafter.
Alternative Options For Insulating Old Roofs
One modern option for existing buildings is sprayed foam. There is a good deal of controversy around these systems. They are often advertised as a DIY option, but those who have done it suggest that it requires skill and experience to do well.
The other issue is more technical and concerns the effect of enclosing roof timbers in a material that can retain moisture. What cannot be argued against is that the sprayed foam sticks very well to whatever it touches — roofing felt, slates or tiles and rafters. If it becomes necessary to remove any of these, the sprayed foam will make it a difficult and expensive job to rectify and is generally considered bad news by many.
Sponsored by ICYNENE
Spray-foam Insulation: Icynene
Icynene is a high performance, spray-foam insulation that expands 100-fold when applied, sealing all gaps service holes and hard to reach spaces where air leakage can occur. It eliminates cold bridging and achieves airtightness standards in excess of those required even for Passivhaus-type construction.
Air leakage accounts for a high proportion of the heat loss from a building and often has a greater impact on the thermal performance than thermal conductivity through walls and roof planes.
Icynene has an open cell structure and soft, yielding texture. This not only provides outstanding insulation for walls lofts and underfloor, but also allows the building to breath naturally, resisting internal condensation – particularly important when insulating older,heritage-type buildings.
Icynene achieves insulation performance well in excess of the U values required under Building Regulations and helps meet the sustainability and zero carbon targets faced by housebuilders.